Will Harvey Weinstein be released from jail after New York Court overturns #MeToo conviction?
Harvey Weinstein, the former film producer who had been convited for rape and sex crimes, has achieved a significant legal victory. According to a report by The Associated Press, his 2020 rape conviction has been overturned by the New York Court of Appeal. However, the decision has sparked a fresh wave of controversy and uncertainty regarding his future legal battles and the ongoing ordeal for survivors of sexual assault.
Want a Loan? Get cash against your Mutual Funds in 4 hoursCourt Decision and Reactions
In a narrow 4-3 verdict, the court deemed Weinstein's trial ‘unfair’ due to the inclusion of testimony from witnesses not directly related to the charges he faced. The majority opinion emphasized that the trial court's decision to allow such testimony was an abuse of judicial discretion, leading to an unfair trial, as mentioned in the report by The Associated Press.
While the majority argued for a new trial, Judge Madeline Singas criticized the decision, stating it ‘perpetuated outdated notions of sexual violence’.
«Order reversed and a new trial ordered,» the ruling said as mentioned in a report by The Associated Press.
«The accused has a right to be held to account only for the crime charged and, thus, allegations of prior bad acts may not be admitted against them for the sole purpose of establishing their propensity for criminality,» wrote Judge Jenny Rivera, in an opinion for the majority, as mentioned in a report by AP.
While Weinstein's spokesperson hailed the decision as a step towards justice, critics,
