Drone pilot can't offer mapping without North Carolina surveyor's license, court says

livemint.com:

The litigation marked an emerging conflict between technology disrupting the hands-on regulated profession of surveying. A state license requires educational and technical experience, which can include examinations and apprenticeships. Jones sought to expand his drone pilot career by taking composite images that could assist construction companies and others with bird's-eye views of their interested tracts of land.

The North Carolina Board of Examiners for Engineers and Surveyors began investigating his activities in late 2018. The board wrote to Jones in June 2019 and ordered him to stop engaging in “mapping, surveying and photogrammetry; stating accuracy; providing location and dimension data; and producing orthomosaic maps, quantities and topographic information." Performing surveying work without a license can subject someone to civil and criminal liability. By then, Jones had placed a disclaimer on his website saying the maps weren't meant to replace proper surveys needed for mortgages, title insurance and land-use applications.

He stopped trying to develop his mapping business but remained interested in returning to the field in the future, according to Monday's opinion. So he sued board members in 2021 on First Amendment grounds. U.S.

District Judge Louise Flanagan sided with the board members last year, determining that the rules withstood scrutiny because they created a generally applicable licensing system that regulated primarily conduct rather than speech. Circuit Judge Jim Wynn, writing Monday's unanimous opinion by the three-member panel, said determining whether such a business prohibition crosses over to a significant speech restriction can be difficult. “Even where a regulation is in fact aimed at